Name:
Location: Tulsa, Oklahoma, Tonga

Sunday, February 05, 2006

Cindy Sheehan, Beverly Young, and that suspicious foreign-looking dude over there

Let's review the list of "Don'ts" for the State of the Union speech. That is, these are tips on what not to wear, to do, or to be if you do not wish to give rise to "reasonable belief" (since "probable cause" is soooo pre-9/11) that you are suspicious, dangerous, or anti-American:

1. Do not wear anything that might make a political statement. Yellow ribbons and flag pins (which seem to have been appropriated by one side in particular) are fine, however.

2. No demonstrations are permitted. Unless you're raising a purple finger and parading around.

3. It's acceptable to interrupt the President's speech with loud applause. You may interrupt as often as you wish. Unless, of course, you're a Democrat and applauding at times when Republicans are not.

4. You may be detained and interrogated as a suspicious person if you are Asian or Middle Eastern. Unless, of course you are Ahmed Chalabi--then you get to sit with Laura.

TIME reported another person pulled out of the SOTU audience last week:

The State of the Union's Mystery Suspect

An anti-war activist and a congressman's wife weren't the only ones
detained by the Capitol PoliceBy MELISSA AUGUST/WASHINGTON

Posted Saturday, Feb. 04, 2006


T-shirts, it turns out, aren't the only things that get you in trouble with the Capitol Police at the State of the Union address. Much has already been made of the fact that both anti-war activist Cindy Sheehan and Beverly Young, the wife of Republican Congressman Bill Young, were ejected from the speech for wearing shirts with political messages; in Sheehan's case, her t-shirt read "2,245 dead. How many more?", while Young was sporting a sweat shirt with the words, "Support the Troops-Defending Our Freedom." Both have denounced their treatment-and both have received apologies from the police.

But on the same evening that President Bush was lauding democracy and freedom, there was one other person in attendance whose rights were infringed upon. The man, who did not want his identity revealed after the disturbing incident, was a personal guest of Florida Democrat Alcee Hastings. He is a prominent businessman from Broward County, Florida who works with the Department of Defense-and has a security clearance. After sitting in the gallery for the entire speech, he was surrounded by about ten law enforcement officers as he exited the chamber and whisked away to a room in the Capitol.

For close to an hour the man, who was born in India but is an American citizen, was questioned by the Police, who thought he resembled someone on a Secret Service photo watch list, according to Capitol Police Chief Terrance Gainer. Eventually, the police realized it was a case of mistaken identity and let him go. Gainer has assured Hastings that the Capitol Police, Secret Service and FBI will investigate why the man was detained for so long, and try to "sharpen our procedures." But the man was "very, very scared" by the incident, says Fred Turner, a spokesperson for Hastings. On Tuesday night, he told the congressman that the experience was "maybe just the price of being brown in America," Turner says.

"He shouldn't have gone through the ringer as long as he did," Gainer says. "He did get caught up in the morass of Secret Service FBI, Capitol Police. Everybody was trying to figure out whether he was a threat. And he absolutely, unequivocally clearly was not." Gainer apologized to the man afterwards, only one of the many apologies he has had to make this week. He met with Congressman Young at least twice, as well as with Young's wife. "There is no prohibition against simply wearing a T-shirt that states your particular cause," Gainer stresses, taking full accountability for not providing clearer direction to his officers.


Gainer says he will work with the House Sergeant at Arms to clarify the rules of the House of Representatives, and to ensure that officers have a better understanding of what constitutes a protest and demonstration. Before he finalizes the new rules, Gainer has asked his staff to look into previous arrests and ejections in the gallery to see what he can learn. One of the first protests at a State of the Union speech occurred in 1916, when President Woodrow Wilson was speaking and a group of suffragettes sitting in the gallery unfurled a large yellow banner with the words, "Mr. President, what will you do for woman suffrage?" The Capitol Police prepared to arrest the women, but the chief doorkeeper ordered them to leave them alone. An assistant doorkeeper on the floor, however, did manage to pull the banner down. Compared to what happened at this week's speech, that almost seems civilized.